SEO and PPC are the two ways to appear on Google. PPC (pay-per-click advertising, usually through Google Ads) puts you at the top of results immediately, but you pay for every click and visibility stops when spending stops. SEO earns unpaid visibility that keeps working once it is built, but it takes time. Most businesses that rely on search benefit from using both, with the balance shifting over time as organic visibility grows.
Whether you should invest in SEO, PPC or both depends on how urgently you need enquiries, how competitive your market is, what a customer is worth and how long you plan to rely on search. This guide compares the two honestly, explains when each makes sense and shows how to use them together so that each one improves the other.
What SEO and PPC actually are
SEO: search engine optimisation
SEO is the work of improving your website so it ranks in Google’s organic, unpaid results. It covers technical improvements, content, on-page optimisation, local SEO and building a reputation that search engines trust. You do not pay Google for these clicks, but you do invest time or money in the work. Our guide to what SEO means explains it in detail.
PPC: pay-per-click advertising
PPC means paying each time someone clicks your ad. On Google, ads are bought through Google Ads, where you choose the searches to target, write ads and set budgets and bids. Ads appear with a “Sponsored” label, usually above and below the organic results.
SEO vs PPC at a glance
| SEO | PPC (Google Ads) | |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Builds over months | Can bring traffic within hours of launch |
| Cost model | Investment in work; no cost per click | Cost per click plus management |
| When you stop paying | Visibility usually declines gradually | Visibility stops immediately |
| Control | Indirect: Google decides rankings | Direct: you choose searches, budgets, times and locations |
| Testing | Slow to test changes | Fast, measurable tests of keywords and messages |
| Searcher perception | Many searchers prefer organic results | Some searchers skip ads; others click them readily |
| Long-term value | Builds an asset that compounds | Value lasts only as long as the spend |
| Risk | Results not guaranteed; algorithm changes | Rising click costs; spend can be wasted without good management |
When PPC should come first
Paid search is usually the better starting point when:
- You need enquiries now. A new business, a new service or a quiet month cannot wait for SEO to build.
- Your site is new. A brand-new website has no organic visibility and will take time to earn it.
- Demand is time-sensitive. Seasonal services, events or short-term offers suit paid campaigns.
- You want to test. Ads show quickly which searches and messages turn into customers, before you invest in content for them.
- Organic results are crowded. For some searches, the organic results are dominated by large directories and national brands, and ads are the realistic route in.
When SEO should come first
SEO is usually the better priority when:
- Click costs are high. In competitive sectors, the cost per click can make paid search expensive to sustain, while organic visibility has no per-click cost.
- You are building for the long term. Every page that ranks keeps working for as long as it is maintained.
- Your customers research before buying. Guides and detailed service pages reach people earlier in their decision, where ads are less effective.
- Your site has technical or content problems. These hurt both channels. A slow, unclear landing page wastes ad spend as well as organic potential.
- Local visibility matters. Map pack results come from your Business Profile, which is built through local SEO.
Why using both usually works best
SEO and PPC are not competitors. Used together, each makes the other more effective:
- Keyword intelligence: the search terms report in Google Ads shows the exact phrases people used before converting, which tells you which searches deserve dedicated SEO pages.
- Message testing: ad headlines that attract clicks suggest page titles and meta descriptions that will do the same organically.
- Covering gaps: ads cover valuable searches where you do not yet rank organically, and budgets can be reviewed as organic positions improve.
- Better landing pages: pages built properly for SEO, with clear information and strong calls to action, often convert ad traffic better too.
- More of the page: appearing in both paid and organic results for your most important searches can increase your share of clicks.
How to decide the balance
There is no universal percentage split. A sensible approach is to decide the balance from your own situation and data:
- Work out what an enquiry is worth. Use your conversion rate from enquiry to customer and the typical profit per customer.
- Estimate the cost per enquiry from ads. Keyword Planner gives indicative click costs; your conversion rate turns those into a cost per enquiry.
- Compare with the value. If paid enquiries are profitable, ads can be scaled. If they are marginal, SEO becomes more important.
- Review regularly. As organic visibility grows for particular searches, test reducing spend on them and watch total enquiries, not just paid ones.
Three illustrative scenarios
These are simplified examples to show the reasoning, not real clients.
A new emergency locksmith in Manchester
Urgent searches, a new website with no visibility and immediate need for work. Start with PPC targeted tightly to the areas covered, alongside setting up a Business Profile and basic local SEO. Shift budget towards SEO as reviews and map visibility build.
An established accountancy firm
Clients research carefully and compare firms, click costs are significant and the firm plans to be around for decades. Prioritise SEO: strong service pages, helpful guides and local visibility. Use a modest PPC budget for the highest-value searches and to test messages.
A growing online shop
Thousands of products, competition from national retailers and marketplaces. Use both: Shopping and search ads for best-sellers and seasonal lines, with e-commerce SEO for category pages that can build organic sales over time.
Measuring SEO and PPC together
To see the true picture, measure both channels in the same place, usually Google Analytics 4, with the same conversion events: WhatsApp clicks, emails, calls and form submissions. Watch for:
- Total enquiries from search, not each channel in isolation.
- Cannibalisation: whether ads on searches where you already rank first organically are bringing extra enquiries or simply replacing free clicks.
- Cost per enquiry for paid, and the trend in organic enquiries over time.
Common mistakes
- Running ads to a homepage instead of a relevant service page
- Using broad keywords without a negative keyword list
- Not tracking conversions, so decisions are based on clicks
- Stopping SEO once ads are working, and becoming dependent on paid traffic
- Treating ad “competition” as a measure of SEO difficulty
- Letting a provider own your Google Ads account and data
Next steps
If you want both channels working from the same research and the same tracking, we offer Google Ads management alongside our SEO services in Manchester. We will tell you honestly where we think your budget would work hardest.